Sick Report: How Employers Can Fight Back Against Malingerers
Employers have legal options to take action against employees faking illness. Find out what steps companies can take if there is suspicion of unjustified sick leave, for example, in the case of conspicuous absences on bridge days.
Sick Leave: How Employers Can Defend Themselves Against Malingerers
Companies face the challenge of managing employee absences due to illness, but not every sick leave notification is plausible. Especially in cases of suspected "malingering"—such as repeated absences on bridge days or Mondays—employers can take legal action to defend themselves and secure operational processes. This affects not only SMEs but also large corporations, as archived reports from the Handelsblatt from September 2026 show. For responsible executives, knowledge of the legal framework is crucial to maintaining trust within the team and effectively addressing unjustified absences.
Suspicion of malingering often arises from conspicuous patterns. For example, if an employee is regularly unfit for work directly after or before weekends or public holidays, these can be indicators. Employers are not defenseless in such cases. One of the first measures is a private one-on-one meeting to clarify the situation. Legally, however, it is decisive that a certificate of incapacity for work (AU) in Germany has a high evidentiary value. This can only be shaken by concrete evidence that raises serious doubts about the accuracy of the certificate. Such doubts may arise, for instance, if the employee engages in a leisure activity despite being on sick leave that delays recovery or is incompatible with the stated illness.
Legal Instruments in Case of Suspicion
If discussions have no effect or the suspicion intensifies, companies have further options. A key measure is involving the Medical Service of the Health Insurance (MDK). Employers can request the MDK to conduct a medical examination of the employee. The MDK then checks whether the incapacity for work actually exists and whether it exists to the reported extent. The result of this assessment can invalidate the evidentiary value of the original AU certificate. If the MDK examination reveals that there is no incapacity for work, this can lead to consequences under labor law, up to and including dismissal, as the employee has grossly breached their duties. However, it should be noted that this process must be legally sound to avoid challenges.
In addition to the MDK examination, employers can, under strict conditions, also take detective measures to gather evidence of malingering. However, this is highly sensitive under data protection law and is only permissible in the event of a concrete, justified suspicion. Any observation must be proportionate and must not violate the employee's personal rights. If legal boundaries are crossed here, the evidence collected may be inadmissible in court and could even harm the company. Comprehensive legal advice is essential here to ensure legally secure steps and avoid damage to reputation.