Column "My Verdict": When Top Earners Are Senior Employees
High salary or responsibility alone do not yet make a senior employee. Learn which criteria are truly decisive according to the Works Constitution Act and the Unfair Dismissal Protection Act, and why correct classification is essential for companies and professionals.
Column "My Verdict": When High Earners Are Considered Executive Employees
Frankfurt, September 12, 2026 – The legal classification of employees with high salaries and significant responsibility as "executive employees" (leitende Angestellte) is by no means a foregone conclusion in the German working world. A current debate highlights that salary level or formal position in the organizational chart alone does not automatically establish the status of an executive employee. However, this distinction is of crucial importance, as it has far-reaching consequences for the applicability of protection against dismissal, working time regulations, and participation in works councils. For companies, incorrect classification poses significant risks, while for specialists and managers, knowledge of these nuances is essential.
The status of the executive employee is primarily defined in Germany in the Works Constitution Act (§ 5 Para. 3 BetrVG) and the Protection Against Dismissal Act (§ 14 Para. 2 KSchG). The decisive factor here is not just the salary level – although this can often be an indicator – but above all the authority to independently make hiring and firing decisions, to hold a general power of attorney (Prokura), or to regularly make other significant decisions that decisively influence the existence and development of the company. Over the years, case law has developed a relatively strict line here, placing the protection of employee rights at the forefront. Numerous lawsuits prove that, in practice, companies often have difficulty meeting the legal requirements for this status.
Consequences for Companies and Employees
For companies, an incorrect classification carries significant legal and financial risks. If an alleged executive employee is classified as an ordinary employee in the event of a dispute, the company may face substantial back payments for overtime, non-compliance with dismissal protection, or the invalid non-involvement of the works council. This uncertainty sometimes leads companies to act more cautiously and not always explicitly declare highly qualified personnel as executive employees, even if their role would suggest it. This, in turn, can reduce the attractiveness for top talent who expect the corresponding status and the associated freedom.
For graduates of MBA and Master's programs, who generally aspire to demanding management positions, this topic is of particular relevance. They are often quickly promoted to positions with high responsibility and corresponding compensation. It is therefore crucial to know one's own rights and obligations exactly and to critically examine the contractually agreed status. An MBA not only imparts business knowledge but also sharpens the understanding of legal frameworks and the importance of precise contract drafting. The ability to understand and interpret such nuances in labor law is one of the important soft skills that can be acquired as part of a sound education.