Leadership: "People need to feel they are allowed to be stupid"

    Philosopher Manuel Scheidegger questions the "failure cult" and the fear of making mistakes in leadership in a Handelsblatt interview. He argues that accepting human fallibility – "being allowed to be stupid" – promotes innovation and shows the limits of AI.

    Leadership: "People must feel they are allowed to be stupid"

    In a recent article, philosopher Manuel Scheidegger focuses on the often underestimated role of "being allowed to be stupid" in effective leadership. Published on September 18, 2026, Scheidegger takes a critical look at how mistakes, failure, and human fallibility are handled in modern working environments. He argues that the widespread fear of stupidity or mistakes paralyzes innovation and learning processes instead of promoting them. This stands in contrast to a corporate culture that aims to allow for genuine creativity and problem-solving skills.

    In this context, Scheidegger also criticizes the often misunderstood "cult of failure," where failing is declared a learning opportunity, but in practice, there is hardly any room for actual experimentation or voicing unfinished thoughts. Instead, a culture of perfection and constant pressure to succeed dominates. He also views the hopes placed in Artificial Intelligence to compensate for human shortcomings from a nuanced perspective. He warns that while AI is efficient, it cannot replace the human capacity for intuition, lateral thinking, and precisely the "permission to be stupid," as these are often the sources of true innovation.

    Scheidegger's remarks are highly relevant for aspiring managers and MBA students. Developing a leadership personality that creates an environment where employees can express ideas, ask questions, and make mistakes without fear of negative consequences is a core competency. Effective leadership, therefore, means not only making the right decisions but also creating the framework in which uncertainty and a willingness to learn are perceived as strengths rather than weaknesses. This requires a shift away from traditional top-down approaches toward more participatory and error-friendly organizational models.

    In the context of increasingly complex global markets and rapid technological development, the ability to manage uncertainty and learn from mistakes becomes a decisive competitive advantage. Scheidegger's concept of "opinion fasting," where one deliberately refrains from premature judgments to create space for new perspectives, could serve as a practical exercise. It underscores the necessity for leaders not only to accumulate knowledge but also to critically reflect on their own mindset and remain open to unconventional approaches.

    The implications for teaching in MBA programs are diverse. They range from imparting coaching and mentoring skills to developing methods for psychological safety in teams. The core message is clear: true innovative power and sustainable success emerge where people have the freedom to experiment and, in doing so, are "allowed to be stupid" at times without having to fear reprisals. Enabling this is one of the most important tasks of modern leadership.