The Career Question: How do I, as a leader, fill big shoes?

    Being a leader is challenging, especially when a popular predecessor set high expectations. Learn from two coaches how to authentically fill big shoes, build trust, and establish your own leadership style.

    Taking on a leadership position always represents a challenge. However, this task becomes particularly demanding when the predecessor was highly popular within the team or department and left behind high expectations. Two experienced leadership coaches shed light on this complex situation and provide recommendations on how new managers can successfully fill these significant shoes. This issue, which frequently arises in everyday professional life, is gaining relevance in light of dynamic career paths and increasing competition for leadership positions, and was most recently addressed by the FAZ in September 2026.

    A change at the top of an organizational unit is often associated with uncertainty, both for the team and for the new leader themselves. If the predecessor was a charismatic personality who significantly shaped the team, employees may initially react with skepticism or insecurity. Coaches emphasize that in such cases, it is crucial not to try to copy the predecessor. Authenticity and the development of one's own leadership style are essential to build credibility and find long-term acceptance. This often requires patience initially and a conscious strategy of integration.

    A central aspect is communication. New leaders should proactively seek dialogue with their team to clarify expectations and address worries or concerns. It is not about changing everything immediately or disparaging the achievements of the predecessor, but rather about listening, understanding, and successively setting one's own accents. A cautious approach when introducing new ideas or processes can help reduce resistance. The coaches advise first consolidating successes and only then gradually developing and communicating one's own visions.

    For aspiring managers considering an MBA program, this topic offers important food for thought. MBA programs do not only impart business knowledge but also place a strong focus on leadership skills, change management, and personal competencies. The ability to successfully settle into new leadership positions, especially in demanding constellations, is a direct result of these educational contents. Case studies and role-plays within an MBA prepare graduates to master such transitions strategically and to shape their own leadership role effectively, rather than merely duplicating a predecessor's role.

    The importance of networking and mentoring should also not be underestimated. Exchanging ideas with experienced leaders who have mastered similar situations can provide valuable insights and solutions. An MBA program promotes the building of such supportive relationships through its cohort structure and alumni networks. Ultimately, it comes down to building trust, bringing in one's own strengths, and aligning the team toward a common future.